The Blue Jays’ Five Greatest Hitters

Number one

Jose Bautista (2008-present)
There haven’t been as many, if any, rags-to-riches tales as celebrated or astonishing as that of Bautista. He struggled as a journeyman major leaguer through his first six years, bouncing around one season with five different organizations and, after finally sticking for a few years with Pittsburgh, was given up on by the Pirates—traded to the Blue Jays one-up for the dreaded “player to be named later.” At first, he played with the same uninspiring commonality in Toronto—but suddenly, late in 2009, he corrected the timing in his swing and became, literally, a reborn baseball hitter.

After hitting .218 with three home runs in his first 86 games of 2009, Bautista hit .280 with ten blasts over his final 27 contests. The splurge continued into 2010, and everyone took notice; it was hard not to given that Bautista slammed his way to a franchise-record 54 homers with 124 RBIs, raising eyebrows everywhere. In the age of steroid suspicion, Bautista’s sudden rise from nomad to All-Star—he had entered 2010 with a career .238 average and never hit more than 16 homers in a season—prompted plenty of murmuring over whether he was juiced up, but Bautsita denied it and his coaches and teammates swore by his natural cleanliness.

Impressed, the Blue Jays re-upped Bautista with a five-year, $65 million pact, crossing their fingers that his 2010 breakout was no fluke. Their hopes would happily be confirmed; though his home run total in 2011 dropped to 43 (which still led the majors), he had a more complete season—raising his average to a career-best .302 and walking 132 times, 24 intentionally. He was also given love from All-Star Game voters who checked his name a then-record 7.4 million times. Injuries curtailed his output from 2012-13, but he still managed to be dangerous when active—knocking out another 55 long balls in 210 games over those two seasons.

Along with the Blue Jays, Bautista waited a long time to get to the postseason—and when he and the Jays finally got there in 2015, he responded by hitting .293 in 41 at-bats with four homers—the most memorable of those being a series-clinching moon shot against Texas in the ALDS, topped by a spectacular bat flip that marveled the baseball public while greatly ticking off the Rangers.

Number two

Carlos Delgado (1993-2004)
Toronto is often a place where major league stars go unnoticed, lest they make a big splash at the All-Star Game or achieve a magnificent feat. Carlos Delgado did the latter—smoking out four home runs on September 25, 2003—and still was often lost in the crowd of steroids era sluggers playing for a team ensconced at the .500 mark.

For Blue Jays fans, there are no lost memories of the Puerto Rican native originally signed by Toronto at age 16. Delgado is the most sustained—and productive—power source in team history accented with a pair of monster years, and is tops on the all-time franchise list in home runs, runs batted in, runs scored and walks.

Raised as a catcher but quickly adapted to the outfield, then first base and, finally, the designated hitter spot, Delgado showed good sock from the start, but was only a career .267 hitter when he entered the 2000 season and ripped opposing pitchers apart—becoming a triple crown threat with a .344 average, 41 homers and 137 RBIs (he also added a team-record 57 doubles). He finished only fourth in the AL MVP vote but was rewarded with a sparkling new contract by the Blue Jays that made him, briefly before Alex Rodriguez’s megadeal with Texas, baseball’s highest annually-paid player.

Delgado’s fantastic 2000 campaign came amid a six-season run in which he averaged 40 homers, 40 doubles, 124 RBIs, 107 runs and 101 walks. His more notable achievements during this stretch, besides the four-homer game, were a pair of three-homer performances just 16 days apart in April 2001 and a major league-leading 145 RBIs in 2003. Delgado somehow was named to just two All-Star Games, and his anonymous existence with the Blue Jays came to a controversial end when, during his final season with Toronto in 2004, he refused to stand during the U.S. national anthem or the seventh-inning playing of God Bless America to protest the American-led Iraq War.

His contract expired, Delgado played one year with Florida and four with the New York Mets before injuries permanently sidetracked his career, which ended with 473 homers.

Bushers Book
Number three

Fred McGriff (1986-90)
The tall, upright first baseman became Toronto property in 1984 when he was yet another New York Yankee prospect hastily traded away during the 1980s for over-the-hill veterans to help George Steinbrenner win instantly—which never happened. (To be fair, McGriff was never going to knock the revered and highly loved Don Mattingly off the depth chart in New York.) The Yankees’ loss was certainly the Blue Jays’ gain; McGriff’s first extended year in Toronto in 1987 led to 20 homers in 295 at-bats, earning the everyday spot for 1988—when he clouted 34 more longballs, followed in 1989 with an AL-best 36. He became so good, it forced a brief exile of another Toronto first base prospect, Cecil Fielder, to Japan.

Bestowed the nickname Crime Dog from ESPN’s Chris Berman because his last name drew parallels to McGruff the Crime Dog, a popular public service cartoon character of the time, McGriff became a pillar of power in the Toronto lineup. But he wasn’t just home runs; he typically hit for a healthy (if not spectacular) average, tipping the .300 mark for the first time in 1990, and his potency at the plate was further enhanced by a knack for drawing walks, averaging nearly 100 a year for the Blue Jays. Despite these impressive early qualifications, McGriff never once made it to an All-Star Game with Toronto.

McGriff’s tenure with the Blue Jays was the beginning of a remarkably steady career in which he always put up big (but not bombastic) numbers, finishing a 19-year career with 493 career round-trippers despite never hitting more than 37 in any one season.

Number four

Edwin Encarnacion (2009-present)
The Dominican native’s career plays almost as a mild variation on Jose Bautista’s baseball life to date: Persistent struggles early in his career, followed by a breakout performance and consistent All-Star-level hitting since.

Encarnacion held great promise but found it hard to fulfill, which led the Cincinnati Reds to give up and send him to Toronto. The Blue Jays essentially followed suit when they placed him on waivers following the 2010 season; he was picked up by Oakland, but just as quickly snagged back by the Blue Jays when the A’s had second thoughts. It took a few more seasons, but Encarnacion finally clicked in 2012 with an impressive 42 homers and 110 RBIs, following that up in each of the next three seasons with 36-104, 34-98 and 39-111 while batting respectively in the upper .200s. Part of his sudden rise to slugging power could be traced to his move away from third base, where he had badly languished as one of the worst fielders at that position. (To wit: his 2011 fielding percentage at the hot corner was a deplorable .892.) Allowed to split more of his time between first base and the designated hitter spot, Encarnacion was able to concentrate more comfortably on his offense; the results were telling.

Power binges and hot streaks have proven to be a habit for Encarnacion, who in 2014 tied Mickey Mantle’s AL record with 16 homers in the month of May; ten of those blasts came over five multi-homer games, a monthly feat previously equaled by only two players in major league history. In 2015, he hit safely in 26 straight games—two shy of the franchise mark.

Number five

Roberto Alomar (1991-95)
When McGriff was shipped away to San Diego along with longtime shortstop stalwart Tony Fernandez after the 1990 season in a deal that irked Toronto fans, it brought to the Blue Jays Joe Carter and one Roberto Alomar, the son of former major leaguer Sandy Alomar and brother of Sandy Alomar Jr., who two years earlier was considered the more talented prospect. But Roberto more than held his own within the Alomar household, helping to ignite a dynasty in Toronto and flourishing to a brilliant Hall-of-Fame career at second base.

Though not blessed with great power, the switch-hitting Alomar could do just about everything else with ease. He hit .307 with the Blue Jays, stole over 50 bases twice and won Gold Gloves every season with Toronto at second base. In the Jays’ three straight postseason appearances from 1991-93—the latter two resulting in world titles—Alomar turned his game up several notches, hitting .373 in 29 games with two homers, 20 RBIs and 18 steals in 20 attempts.

Alomar’s best years by the numbers were still to come after he left Toronto via free agency in 1996 for Baltimore and, later, Cleveland; but he never recaptured the glory of his World Series success with the Blue Jays, and became a pariah in the eyes of many in a single moment when, playing in Toronto at the end of his first year with the Orioles, he spit in the face of umpire John Hirschbeck after arguing balls and strikes—and further dug a huge public hole when he stated that Hirschbeck had grown “bitter” since the death of his son. The incident left a permanent stain—and likely delayed induction into the Hall of Fame, 15 years later—on a swashbuckling career in which Alomar hit an even .300 with 2,724 hits, 474 steals and ten Gold Gloves.

Toronto Blue Jays Team History: Year-by year records, statistics and an oral history of the Blue Jays, decade by decade.

The Blue Jays' Five Greatest Pitchers: A list of the five greatest pitchers based on their productivity and efficiency.

The Blue Jays' Five Greatest Games: A list of five memorable games and other notable personal achievements that have defined the Blue Jays' history.

How did This Great Game determine the list of the Blue Jays' five greatest hitters? Find out here.

share this page with a friendShare this page with a friend.

Have a comment, question or request? Contact us at This Great Game.

© 2016 This Great Game.

All-Time Blue Jays Batting Leaders

Batting Average
Paul Molitor
Roberto Alomar
Frank Catalanotto
Shannon Stewart
Tony Fernandez

Carlos Delgado
Vernon Wells
Lloyd Moseby
Tony Fernandez
George Bell

Tony Fernandez
Vernon Wells
Carlos Delgado
Lloyd Moseby
George Bell

Carlos Delgado
Vernon Wells
Tony Fernandez
Lloyd Moseby
George Bell

Tony Fernandez
Lloyd Moseby
Alfredo Griffin
Willie Upshaw
Alex Rios, Roberto Alomar

Home Runs
Carlos Delgado
Jose Bautista
Vernon Wells
Joe Carter
George Bell

Runs Batted In
Carlos Delgado
Vernon Wells
George Bell
Joe Carter
Lloyd Moseby

Carlos Delgado
Jose Bautista
Lloyd Moseby
John Olerud
Tony Fernandez

Stolen Bases
Lloyd Moseby
Roberto Alomar
Damaso Garcia
Tony Fernandez
Shannon Stewart

All statistics are through the 2015 season. Batting average leaders are based on players with 1,500 or more plate appearances. Bold type indicates active Blue Jays player.

This Great Game at CafePress