The Mariners’ Five Greatest Hitters
Ken Griffey Jr. (1989-99, 2009-10)
Born on the same day (November 21) and town (Donora, Pennsylvania) as Stan Musial, The Kid followed The Man to superstardom and became the face of the Mariners after 12 years of constant losing and a parade of fleeting, fringe star ballplayers in Seattle.
Arriving in the Emerald City with great fanfare, Griffey was reunited during his second and third seasons with his father (former Cincinnati Bid Red Machine cog Ken Griffey Sr.) for onsite tutoring with a genealogical bent. The pair made history when they became the first father-and-son combo to play together on the same team, and in a 1990 game they even hit back-to-back home runs.
After showing sure but steady improvement to go with modest power over his first four years, Griffey broke out as a big-time slugger in 1993—surpassing 40 homers for the first of seven times in his career, including long shots in eight straight games to tie a record. In 1994, Griffey was one of a handful of players in hot pursuit of Roger Maris’ season home run record—before the season-ending labor strike cut short his chase with 40 notched in 111 games. (He was on pace for 58.) A fast starter, Griffey set records in 1994 with 32 homers before the end of June, and 13 during April 1997. (Both marks have since been broken.)
The home run parade continued unabated through the rest of Griffey’s time in Seattle; he launched 49 jacks in 1996, a career-high 56 in 1997 to help the Mariners set an all-time team mark with 264, added another 56 in 1998—including his 300th career shot, making him the second youngest player to reach the milestone—and 48 more in 1999, a year split between the bandboxed Kingdome and the more pitching-friendly Safeco Field, which opened that year. He was a deserving All-Star and Gold Glove winner in center field for all but his rookie year in Seattle.
By now considered the heir apparent to Hank Aaron’s all-time career home run mark, Griffey—with a year left on his contract—made it well known that he wanted to play for the Reds, where his father performed and where many family and friends resided. (He reportedly also made grumblings about Safeco Field’s cool, heavy marine air and worried that he wouldn’t be able to catch Aaron playing half his games there.) Rather than lose Griffey outright to free agency, the Mariners traded him to the Reds a year before his current pact expired. Seattle’s loss would ultimately become Griffey’s as well; in eight-plus years in Cincinnati, his play gradually began to regress and he missed 460 games mostly due to a long line of injuries that cost him his shot at reaching Aaron.
At age 39, Griffey returned to the Mariners for an encore that magnificently paled to his first tour of duty in Seattle; he provided some pop but little else (hitting .214) in 2009, then lost the power completely in 2010 amid accusations of clashing with manager Don Wakamatsu and nodding off in the clubhouse during games. He announced his retirement two months into the season, returning once again a year later to the Mariners in a front office capacity.
Griffey’s 630 career home runs currently place him sixth on the all-time list, and he’s one of the few sluggers during the steroid era who has been considered clean of using performance-enhancing drugs. That certainly made him a favorite with Hall-of-Fame voters who, early in 2016, punched his name on 99.3% of the ballots—the highest percentage for any player, ever.
Edgar Martinez (1987-2004)
Few players have taken better advantage of the designated hitter role as has Martinez, whose already shaky defense at third base took an essentially permanent hit in 1993 when he suffered a major knee injury during an exhibition game in Vancouver, Canada.
To that point, the left-handed hitting New York native had evolved into an outstanding hitter and was coming off an AL batting title with a .343 average. Recovered and playing DH full-time by 1995, he won a second batting crown, recording a career-high .356 while showing off a newfound penchant as a hitting machine with very good power and a sharp eye; over the next seven years through 2001, Martinez would hit .330 and average 28 home runs, 110 RBIs, 100 runs and 107 walks per season. His five on-base percentage readings from 1995-99 (topping out at .479 in 1995) are the five highest in Mariners team history. Martinez left his glove in the clubhouse but rarely needed it; in his final ten seasons, he only made 34 appearances on the field, usually in emergency or mop-up situations.
Martinez’s first postseason series was a whopper; he hit .571 (12-for-21) with three doubles, two homers, ten RBIs and six walks in the Mariners’ thrilling five-game ALDS triumph over the New York Yankees in 1995. Otherwise, he was a bust in October throughout his career, hitting just .206 in 29 other playoff games.
A seven-time All-Star and lifetime .312 hitter who holds Seattle franchise records with 514 doubles, 1,261 RBIs and 1,283 walks, the offensively gifted but defensively inept Martinez is a challenging case for Hall-of-Fame voters knowing that, had he played before the advent of the DH, he may not have stuck around for nowhere near as long.
Alex Rodriguez (1994-2000)
Born in New York City and raised in Miami, where the Mariners drafted him straight out of high school as the majors’ number one pick in 1993, Rodriguez needed very little time in the minors to prove he was ready for the big time—debuting as an 18-year old for Seattle and, two years later, stunning baseball with a monster breakout year in which he hit a major league-high .358 on 215 hits with 54 doubles, 36 homers, 123 RBIs and 141 runs scored. Quite clearly, a superstar was born.
After a relatively quiet (.300-23-84) 1997 encore, Rodriguez returned to dominant form over the next three seasons for the Mariners, starting with a 1998 campaign in which he led the AL with 213 hits and becoming, after Jose Canseco and Barry Bonds (both of whom would later be proven as steroid users along with Rodriguez during their careers), the third major leaguer to hit 40 homers with 40 steals in the same season. Rodriguez hit over 40 homers again in 1999 and 2000, easily adding well over 100 runs and RBIs in each season while hitting close to or over the .300 mark; in 15 career playoff games for the Mariners, he hit .340 with three homers.
Unlike Griffey, the Mariners held onto Rodriguez through the final year of his existing contract in hopes of retaining him with a long-term deal. Like Griffey, Rodriguez scorned Safeco Field and publicly hinted on his own web site that he might stay—if the Mariners moved the fences in. (The Mariners would—13 years later.) In the end, hopes of Rodriguez and his mercenary agent Scott Boras accepting a hometown discount to stay in Seattle would come off as delusional as the Texas Rangers handed A-Rod a ten-year, $252 million deal that doubled the largest contract ever given to a pro athlete to that moment.
Seattle fans never forgave Rodriguez for leaving; whether as a Ranger or (later) a Yankee, he was vociferously booed whenever he returned to Safeco Field in the enemy’s uniform. The audible pummeling perhaps affected A-Rod, who after leaving the Mariners hit just .251 at Safeco Field—nearly 50 points below his overall career average.
Bret Boone (1992-93, 2001-05)
A third-generation major leaguer, after father Bob Boone and grandfather Ray Boone (not to mention the older brother of Aaron Boone) the humble-sized second baseman began his career with the Mariners before being dealt around the National League for seven years with modest results—then returned to Seattle in 2001 with an absolute bang, hitting .331 (nearly 80 points above his career average) and belting a career-shattering 37 homers with 141 RBIs to finish third in the AL MVP vote and hoist the Mariners to their record-breaking 116-46 season.
Boone attributed his out-of-nowhere campaign to hard exercise, weightlifting and dieting; Jose Canseco intimated in his infamous book Juiced that steroids might have been more behind the muscular and statistical spurt. Nevertheless, Boone leveled off over the next three years but remained a major threat, hovering around the 30-homer, 100-RBI mark through 2004; he made history with teammate Mike Cameron in 2002 when they hit back-to-back home runs—and did it again later in the same inning.
Hitting aside, Boone’s late-career boom also made him better defensively, winning three of his four career Gold Glove awards from 2002-04.
Ichiro Suzuki (2001-2012)
A sensational singles hitter with quick feet, great defense and not much else, Suzuki transcended the Asian experience in North America by becoming the first genuine Japanese-born superstar in the majors.
Often referred to by his first name only, Suzuki arrived in Seattle for 2001 after accomplishing seven straight batting titles in Japan for the Orix Blue Wave. Unlike previous Japanese stars attempting to conquer America, Suzuki didn’t find the majors to be any tougher—nabbing a batting crown, AL Rookie of the Year and AL MVP honors with a .350 average, 242 hits and 56 steals. He continued his success in the 2001 playoffs (his only postseason activity for the Mariners), hitting .421 in ten games. An instant sensation, Suzuki commanded attention from both sides of the Pacific—especially in Japan, where media and fans practically obsessed over his every move.
Using a batting motion common among Japanese ballplayers—swooping at pitches while pulling himself away toward first base—Suzuki maintained excellence at the plate in record-breaking fashion for a decade. In each of his first ten years with Seattle, he collected at least 200 hits (a record run that includes an all-time season mark of 262 hits in 2004, leading to his second batting title at .372), hit over .300, was named to the All-Star Game and earned Gold Glove honors for outfielding excellence. All four streaks came to an end in 2011.
When traded midway through the 2012 season to the New York Yankees, Suzuki stood as the all-time Mariners leader with 2,533 hits, 438 steals and a .322 batting average; with later stays with the Yankees and Miami Marlins, he’s become the first Asian-born major leaguer born to accumulate 3,000 hits—and he’s totaled over 4,000 professional hits between Japan and North America. He’s always been popular in Seattle, in the stands if not in the clubhouse—where some teammates over the years accused him of playing for himself, not for the team. Nevertheless, Suzuki looks likely to become the first Japanese native to enter the Hall of Fame.
Seattle Mariners Team History: Year-by year records, statistics and an oral history of the Mariners, decade by decade.
The Mariners' Five Greatest Pitchers: A list of the five greatest pitchers based on their productivity and efficiency.
The Mariners' Five Greatest Games: A list of five memorable games and other notable personal achievements that have defined the Mariners' history.
How did This Great Game determine the list of the Mariners' five greatest hitters? Find out here.
Have a comment, question or request? Contact us at This Great Game.
© 2017 This Great Game.