The Orioles’ Ten Greatest Pitchers
Jim Palmer (1965-84)
The suave-looking Palmer, handsome enough to be a favorite of women by posing in underwear ads even after his Hall-of-Fame career was done, was the ace of aces on the great Orioles staffs of the 1960s and 1970s. That he never reached the 300-win barrier seems surprising, given that he was an eight-time 20-game winner and recipient of three AL Cy Young Awards. (Various injuries, some of them quite severe, were the culprits in keeping Palmer “restricted” to 268 career victories.)
Palmer introduced himself to mainstream baseball audiences when, nine days shy of his 21st birthday, he became the youngest pitcher to throw a shutout in a World Series when he blanked the Los Angeles Dodgers on four hits in Game Three of the 1966 Fall Classic. He would go on to appear in all six Baltimore World Series to date and compile a career 8-3 postseason record with a 2.61 earned run average.
Though he never got along with long-time Orioles manager Earl Weaver (with a feud that came to unfortunate light during a good-natured roast that turned ugly in 2000), Palmer made it hard for the feisty pilot to do anything but keep him number one in the rotation. And over 3,948 innings, Palmer never allowed a grand slam or back-to-back home runs.
A year after being enshrined in Cooperstown, Palmer made an ill-fated comeback attempt at age 45 with the Orioles, lasting just one appearance in spring training.
Mike Mussina (1991-2000)
The lean right-hander never won a “big” game or a Cy Young Award, but he was always a winner during his decade-long tenure in Baltimore, compiling a 147-81 record for the Orioles before moving on to the New York Yankees; his only full-time losing campaign occurred in his last as an Oriole, when he finished 11-15 in 2000. What Mussina was best remembered for was his constant inability to just miss winning 20 games; with Baltimore, he twice won 19 and, twice, won 18. Had it not been for the 1994-95 players strike, Mussina (who won 16 in 1994 and 19 in 1995) would have likely reached the milestone at least once. (He finally won 20 for the Yankees in 2008—his last season.) Even when Mussina’s ERA wasn’t scintillating, he managed to keep winning, as most notably recalled in 1996 when he won 19 games despite a substandard 4.81 mark. Mussina helped himself out on defense by winning four Gold Glove awards for the Orioles.
Mike Cuellar (1969-76)
A master of the screwball, the Cuban-born Cuellar was a prime part of the parade of 20-game winners under the steerage of manager Weaver, averaging 21 victories per season over a six-year period (1969-74).
Following four well-thrown but frustrating seasons with Houston, Cuellar became a happy man in his first year at Baltimore by posting a 23-11 and 2.38 ERA, resulting in co-ownership of the AL Cy Young Award with Detroit ace Denny McLain. He followed that up a year later by winning an AL-best, career-high 24 games against just eight losses; he recorded his final 20-win campaign in 1974, at age 37, with a 22-10 record. Cuellar finally ran out of gas two years later when he finished 4-13.
Urban Shocker (1918-24)
The best pitcher of the franchise’s St. Louis Browns days was given grandfathered permission to keep throwing the spitball after the pitch had been banned in 1920, but he rarely used it—instead using the threat of it to mess with opposing hitters’ minds. Scooped up originally by the New York Yankees after he had thrown 54 straight scoreless innings in the International League, he was traded to the Browns in a 1918 move that Yankee manager Miller Huggins would quickly regret. With St. Louis, Shocker won 20 or more games in four straight seasons, highlighted with an AL-best 27 victories in 1921. The Yankees got him back in 1925 and gave him four solid campaigns that somewhat paled with his time in St. Louis—and after suddenly being released in 1928, he developed heart problems and passed away in September at age 37.
Dave McNally (1962-74)
Like many pitchers who came to the Orioles in the late 1950s and early 1960s, McNally debuted in Baltimore before he could legally drink, making his first major league assignment at the age of 19. And like many of those pitchers, McNally succeeded—winning 20 or more games in four straight campaigns (1968-71) and leading the AL (along with teammate Cuellar) in 1970 with 24. And like Palmer, McNally threw a four-hit shutout of the Dodgers in the 1966 World Series—with his blanking finishing off the four-game sweep. His heroics at the Fall Classic extended to the batter’s box, where he homered against the New York Mets in the 1969 Series—and a year later, became the only pitcher to date to hit a grand slam in a World Series when he cleaned the bases against Cincinnati in Game Three.
McNally had a knack for winning streaks: Three times he won at least 12 straight decisions, including a run of 17 that tied an AL mark (to be later broken by Roger Clemens); 15 of those 17 wins started the 1969 season, tying another mark that still exists.
After his reign in Baltimore, McNally became known for challenging the longstanding reserve clause by playing without a contract for the Montreal Expos, in essence allowing him to become a free agent after the season; an arbitrator ultimately ruled for McNally and Andy Messersmith (who also played out his option year) to open the door for modern free agency.
Steve Barber (1960-67)
Barber was a wild pitcher with uneven results throughout his career due to chronic pains that kept him from stringing together consecutive campaigns of success. His inability to hit the strike zone was apparent from the outset—in his rookie year, he walked more batters (113) than he struck out in 181.2 innings and racked up a career-high 130 walks in 1961, but it didn’t stop him from still being effective, registering 10-7 and 18-12 marks in those first two years with ERAs close to 3.00. Barber won 20 games in 1963, but injury issues continued to hamper his long-term outlook. The 1967 season—Barber’s last in Baltimore—was a wild contrast of ups and downs; in his first start of the year he came within two outs of a no-hitter, and two weeks later was but an out away from another against Detroit—and lost it when the Tigers notched a run on two walks (Barber allowed ten on the day) and an error before being removed from the game. Barber became a mess afterward and was traded to the Yankees at midseason.
Carl Weilman (1912-20)
The tall (6’5”) Browns’ workhorse for much of the 1910s was a perennial contender for the AL ERA title—finishing as high as third with a 2.06 mark in 1919—but his team was a perennial loser and he finished his career with a undeserving sub-.500 record. Not helping matters was Weilman’s deteriorating health; he had a kidney removed early in 1917 and missed the rest of that season as well as all of the 1918 campaign, and he died of an illness in 1924 at the age of 34, just four years after pitching his last major league game. Weilman may have been paid the ultimate compliment from Ty Cobb, who said he was more trouble than any other pitcher he had ever faced.
Milt Pappas (1957-65)
One of the prime components of the so-called “Diaper Squad” or “Kiddie Korps” of the early 1960s in Baltimore, Pappas made his major league debut for the Orioles at age 18 and gradually evolved into a trustworthy member of the rotation, winning 110 games over nine years without once suffering a losing campaign for the O’s. Unfortunately for Pappas, it was he who was traded to Cincinnati in the deal that brought Frank Robinson to the Orioles; while Baltimore went on to win its first world title with Robinson, Pappas began a far less happy baseball life with the Reds, frequently butting heads with teammates and management while fans unfairly booed him for what he represented as Robinson’s “replacement.”
Harry Howell (1904-10)
Like Weilman, Howell was a terrific pitcher victimized by his presence on a deadweight second division team. His ERAs in a tremendous five-year run with St. Louis between 1904-08 were 2.19, 1.98, 2.11, 1.93 and 1.89—and yet his record during this stretch was 77-90. Howell’s stingy efforts came courtesy of a heavily-used spitball learned from Jack Chesbro in his prior time at New York—a pitch so gunked up with spit that even if his infielders winced at that thought of fielding something so slobbered as if it had been handed to them by an over-salivated dog. (It also didn’t help their defense; of the 549 runs Howell allowed as a Brown, a third of them were unearned.) In 1909, Howell tore his shoulder early and never recovered, pitching his final game a year later.
Howell was no stranger to controversy; he was a handsome ladies’ man, which was fine except that he was already married (and then divorced, in 1907); and on the final day of the 1910 season, a retired Howell—now a coach for the Browns—infamously attempted to bribe a scorer to credit as many hits as possible for Cleveland’s Nap Lajoie, who was neck-and-neck with the hated Ty Cobb in a widely followed batting race. He was banished from baseball for his actions.
Mike Boddicker (1980-88)
Using a combination of a change-up and screwball called a “foshball,” Boddicker patiently awaited his chance to crack the venerable Orioles rotation and finally got in when Mike Flanagan went down with an injury in early 1983. Boddicker made the most of his big break; he was 16-8 in 26 starts with a 2.77 ERA and an AL-best five shutouts, and in that year’s postseason he threw two complete games—a five-hit shutout of Chicago in the ALCS and a three-hitter (allowing just an unearned run) against Philadelphia in the World Series; both gems came in Game Two of those respective series after the Orioles had lost the opener, never to lose again in each series. A year later, Boddicker followed up his impressive rookie effort with an equally fantastic effort, leading the AL with 20 wins and a 2.79 ERA (he lost the Cy Young Award to Detroit reliever Willie Hernandez).
After this sterling start, Boddicker suddenly became hittable with annual ERAs straying beyond the 4.00 mark, but still managed enough wins to remain a valuable asset to the rotation. He became a victim of the Orioles’ wretched 0-21 start in 1988, traded in midseason to the contending Boston Red Sox.
Baltimore Orioles Team History: Year-by year records, statistics and an oral history of the Orioles, decade by decade.
The Braves' Ten Greatest Hitters: A list of the ten greatest pitchers based on their productivity and efficiency.
The Braves' Ten Greatest Games: A list of ten memorable games and other notable personal achievements that have defined the Orioles' history.
How did This Great Game determine the list of the Orioles' ten greatest hitters? Find out here.
Have a comment, question or request? Contact us at This Great Game.
© 2016 This Great Game.